Understanding the Core of Pitch Selection

Every pitcher has a unique arsenal — fastballs, breaking balls, off-speed pitches, and specialty throws. The secret isn’t just knowing what each pitch does, but when and MLB The Show 25 Stubs why to use it.

Fastballs (Four-Seam, Two-Seam, Cutter): Fastballs set the tone. The four-seamer is straight and quick, perfect for getting ahead in the count. The two-seamer adds movement, ideal for inducing grounders. A cutter can break bats when thrown inside to same-handed hitters.

Breaking Balls (Slider, Curveball, Sweeper): These pitches move sharply and can fool hitters if used properly. A slider’s late horizontal break is deadly after establishing a fastball, while a well-placed curveball can drop into the zone after a high heater.

Off-Speed Pitches (Changeup, Splitter, Forkball): These are timing disruptors. They look like fastballs but arrive slower, causing hitters to swing early. Use them sparingly and in unpredictable counts for maximum effect.

Specialty Pitches (Sinker, Knuckleball, Slurve): These can serve as your “out” pitch — something unique that sets your style apart. The sinker, in particular, is a ground-ball machine when located low in the zone.

Understanding how each pitch works allows you to form combinations that exploit hitter tendencies and maximize deception.

Situational Pitching – When Strategy Matters Most

Pitch selection should also depend on the situation. A smart pitcher tailors their approach based on count, runners, and game state.

Ahead in the Count (0–2, 1–2): Don’t give in. Expand the zone with breaking balls or off-speed pitches just outside the strike zone.

Behind in the Count (2–0, 3–1): Go to your most reliable strike pitch, usually a fastball or sinker. Avoid hanging breaking balls — those get crushed.

Double Play Situations: Use pitches with downward movement like sinkers or changeups low in the zone to induce ground balls.

Late-Game Pressure: When fatigue sets in, simplify your approach. Stick to cheap MLB Stubs your two best pitches and focus on precision over power.